\ Inflated Minuteman Numbers, Report Finds

Anti-Immigration Movement

Newspapers Inflated Minuteman Numbers, Report Finds

 

 
A new study of media coverage shows that a large number of daily
newspapers wildly exaggerated the number of volunteers who actually
took part in the Minuteman Project, a vigilante "citizens border
patrol" operation that took place in southeastern Arizona over the
month of April 2005.

The report, "Creating the Minutemen," is based on an American Civil
Liberties Union (ACLU) analysis of 581 articles and editorials printed
in major U.S. newspapers between January 2005 and February 2006. The
ACLU has been highly critical of the Minutemen, and ACLU volunteers
closely monitored the group.

The first of those articles, "Volunteers Set to Monitor Border
Crossings," by Jerry Seper of the hard-right Washington Times,
reported that 240 volunteers had signed up. By early March, Seper was
reporting that the number of volunteers had "more than tripled," came
from every state, and included 16 pilots with aircraft.

During the last two weeks of March 2005, the media hype shifted into
overdrive. Fifteen journalists reported the Minuteman Project had
signed up "at least 1,000 volunteers." The Inland Valley Daily
Bulletin ran a March 23, 2005, article headlined "2,000 volunteers
expected for Minuteman Project."

Vastly fewer actually showed up. During the first week of the project,
The New York Times, the Houston Chronicle, the Chicago Tribune, and
the Los Angeles Times all reported "between 100 and 200" volunteers
(an Intelligence Report story estimated fewer than 150). Even Jerry
Seper of The Washington Times, the Minuteman Project's most prolific
cheerleader, reported just 100 volunteers in his April 3 article,
"Border-vigil Volunteers Big in Spirit, Not Number."

The majority of those volunteers went home after the first weekend,
and while others trickled in over the course of the month-long
operation, the Minuteman Project never came close to matching its
opening strength. "Yet, mysteriously, by the end of the month the
Minutemen were claiming they had 857 volunteers," the ACLU study
reports. Journalists reporting from their desks in faraway cities
failed to challenge the increasingly outrageous claims of the
project's organizers, often publicizing their numbers as simple fact,
without attribution.

On April 16, Seper reported in The Washington Times that over 600
volunteers were on the border. "According to Seper's earlier report,
this would have required more than 500 volunteers showing up within
thirteen days from when he reported fewer than 100 had showed up the
first weekend … a 500% increase," the ACLU report notes. "It did not
take long for the rest of the media to follow Seper's unexplainable leap."

Three days later, on April 19, The Arizona Republic reported 760
volunteers and quoted Minuteman Project co-founder Chris Simcox
claiming he'd signed up 10,000 more for future operations. Another
Seper article that same day reported 800 volunteers. During the final
week of April, Seper reported 820 volunteers and quoted Simcox
claiming 15,000 new sign-ups. The San Francisco Chronicle on April 30
reported 857 volunteers. That number is now cable news gospel.

By February 2006, Seper had written 52 articles on the Minuteman
Project, far more than any other journalist. When Simcox announced a
second Minuteman border operation in California in October 2005, Seper
wrote in an Oct. 1 article that more than 4,000 volunteers were
expected, and later reported that 2,000 had actually participated. In
fact, the turnout was dismal. An Intelligence Report staff writer
counted just 26 Minuteman volunteers over a three-day period.

Since April 2005, the Minuteman Project has morphed into a national
movement, with multiple splinter groups and spin-offs increasingly
targeting immigrants far from the border. The ACLU report shows how
newspaper reporting that was either lazy or deliberately misleading
helped transform a relatively small band of extremists into the armed

vanguard of the anti-immigration movement.

Intelligence Report
Summer 2006
 
 
 

 
    

------ End of Forwarded Message

__._,_.___

Messages in this topic (1) Reply (via web post) | Start a new topic

Messages | Files | Photos | Links | Database | Polls | Members | Calendar

Change settings via the Web (Yahoo! ID required)
Change settings via email: Switch delivery to Daily Digest | Switch format to Traditional
Visit Your Group | Yahoo! Groups Terms of Use | Unsubscribe

Recent Activity

 3

New Members

Visit Your Group

SPONSORED LINKS

• Civil right lawyer
• Civil rights
• Civil right attorney
• Civil right attorney california
• Nlg

Yahoo! TV

Staying in tonight?

Check listings to

see what is on.

Y! Toolbar

Get it Free!

easy 1-click access

to your groups.

Yahoo! Groups

Start a group

in 3 easy steps.

Connect with others.

.

__,_._,___